Red Racing Horses

Make a New Account



Forget your username or password?


Red Racing Horses analyzes and discusses elections from a Republican-leaning perspective. Thank you for visiting, and we hope you'll enjoy the blog. Please read our site Terms of Use.

~The RRH Moderators: BostonPatriot, Daniel Surman, GoBigRedState, Greyhound, Izengabe, James_Nola, Right Reformer, Ryan_in_SEPA, and Shamlet.

Problems logging into your account? Inside information? Complaints? Compliments? E-Mail us at: We check it often!

An Important Announcement about Upcoming Changes to RRH

The Current RRH Race Ratings:



Row Officers

2014 very preliminary senate picture.

by: AJNolte

Fri Nov 09, 2012 at 17:13:08 PM EST

I had this diary written as one massive post, attempting to cover all of the 2014 senate and governor's races that could potentially be competitive. Instead, I'll break them up, but post them consecutively. For those who haven't picked up on this in my comments, I'm totally blind, which means I have no earthly idea if this is going to look write to sighted viewers. If there's anything I can do to make the visual experience better, please let me know.

The 2012 election is over, so bring on 2014 (and considering 2012, not a moment too soon for Republicans). The good news is that the list of senate seats up in 2014 looks promising for Republicans. The bad news, of course, is that they looked even more promising in 2012. Without further ado, but with much fear and trembling, here's a list of the potentially competitive senate elections in 2014.

Georgia. This one almost didn't make the list; if Saxby Chambliss held out in the tough year of 2008, he'll probably do so again in 2014. However, Democrats do seem to gun for him, so I wouldn't be surprised to see them give it a try. I have no idea who their strongest candidate might be here, since I doubt John Barrow will take the plunge.

Kentucky. See GA above: McConnell will be targeted, and will probably win comfortably despite immense hype from Democrats about the greatness of their nominee.

Maine. Susan Collins has this seat as long as she wants it; the question is, does she follow Snowe into retirement? With no King Angus on the horizon, expect Pingree, Michaud or both to run if Collins bows out; this would be a very likely pick-up for team blue, unless Elliott Cutler decided to jump in and screw things up for them. Bottom line: if we want a shot at taking the senate in 2014, we need Collins to stick around.

South Carolina. Lindsey Graham is one of those Republicans who always seems to be on the verge of getting primaried, and rumor has it state senator Tom Davis may pull the trigger in 2014. Graham's got plenty of time, and should probably hire some of Hatch's people from 2012. Democrats report 99% confidence that retired veteran and sometime accidental comedian Alvin Greene will not be on the scene as their nominee in this race, but regardless, this isn't a pick-up opportunity for them.


Alaska. With his incredibly narrow win over a scandal-plagued incumbent in the Democratic banner year of 2008, Mark Begich could be a prime target for Republicans in 2014 (of course, we said the same thing about John Tester...). Possible contenders could include Governor Sean Parnell or Lieutenant Governor Mead Treadwell. Parnell's primary challenge to Don Young in 2008 indicates he could be interested in going to Washington, but if he decides to run for reelection, Treadwell, previously the head of the Arctic Research Commission and a successful businessman with an Ivy league pedigree, might be a really solid recruit.

Arkansas. This one looks great for team red on paper. Arkansas has been going our way, after remaining stubbornly blue down-ballot. Unfortunately, even if Pryor retires here (and he's said he's running again), Democrats could potentially have a great recruit in Governor Mike Beebe. The strongest recruit for us here is almost certainly congressmen, and former U.S. attorney, Tim Griffin. A lot of people really love freshmen elect Tom Cotton, but it's probably a bit early for him to run here.

Colorado. This is a swing state that's been stubbornly eluding team red, but Mark Udall could be vulnerable to a very strong candidate in a wave year. Jane Norton, Mike Kaufmann, Josh Penry and Attorney General John Suthers are possibilities, though at least one of them is likely to run for governor. Suthers, who has won statewide twice and racked up a 14-point margin in 2010, would be a real force in the race, but has declined to run for senate twice before, in 2008 and 2010.

Louisiana. In all likelihood, we already know who the contenders will be in this one. A plugged-in friend across the isle tells me Mary Landrieu is planning to run, and run on Obamacare. Expect Bill Cassidy to challenge her; I can't think of any other reason to build up a multi-million dollar war chest in a district as safe as his.

Minnesota. Al Franken's narrow win pretty much guarantees his place on this list. Despite Democratic talk on this site about how Franken's kept his head down and made Minnesota Nice with everyone for his first term, I can't imagine a well-funded challenge to the liberal lightning-rod not happening. If, however, it looks like Franken's going to win anyway, we might as well throw Bachmann at this race, and get her out of that safe seat in which she constantly manages to under-perform. I'd prefer Coleman, Pawlenty or Paulsen of course (and Ramstad would be better than Franken), but if we really can't win it, we might as well lose with someone who will give us a shot at another race by getting out of the way.

Montana. If Obamacare functions as perfectly as Democrats think it will, Max Baucus is probably perfectly safe here. Even if it doesn't, Republicans seem to have serious bench issues in what should be a red state. This one should be on the radar, but I'm pretty down on Montana after Rehburg's loss.

New Hampshire. Jeanne Shaheen's win in 2010 was narrow, and New Hampshire seems to be one of those states that's good to Republicans in midterm years. Is there anyone on our potential bench here who's last name isn't Sununu?

New Jersey. I only put this one in the to-watch pile for two reasons. First, Frank Lautenberg's almost certainly on the retirement watch list. Second, if Chris Christie really wants to be President, he's got some serious fence-mending to do with the Republican base and establishment in loo of the past week and a half. Getting a Republican elected to the Senate from New Jersey should, logically, be a priority for a presidentially-focused Christie. Candidates could include LG Kim Guadagno or NJ-03 rep John Runyan. If Lautenberg retires, Democrats could run either Newark mayor Cory Booker or representative Rob Andrews.

North Carolina. Kay Hagan is another quite vulnerable Democrat on this list. Republicans have a plethora of potential candidates, and the state actually swung back to Republicans in 2012. Speaker of the NC house Thom Tillis is a rumored candidate, and his strong ties to Republicans across the state and self-funding potential make him look like a great one on paper.

Oregon. Ordinarily, I wouldn't put Jeff Merkley on the list because of the blueness of Oregon, but Republicans actually had a pretty good 2010 in the state, and if 2014 shapes up similarly, Merkley could be a target. Greg Walden is a rumored candidate, but will probably want to keep moving up in the house. Other potentials include former co-speaker of the house Bruce Hanna, state senator Jason Atkinson and former senator Gordon Smith. Interestingly-and surprisingly-preliminary PPP polls show Merkley at or below 43% in match-ups with all of them (though Smith wasn't polled).

South Dakota. Is it possible to over-state the popularity of former SD governor Mike Rounds? I'd say, his approval ratings were nye on Hoevenesque, and if his rumored candidacy becomes a reality, I wouldn't be surprised to see Johnson make a Dorganesque move. The only things which would keep Rounds from Hoven numbers in an open seat scenario would be Democrats' residual anger over the abortion ban and his CREW ranking. Unlike Heidi Heitkamp in North Dakota, I don't think Democrats have a white knight to save them if Johnson retires, and even if he doesn't, the race is probably at least tilt R with Rounds.

Virginia. If Mark Warner stays in this seat (which looks likely), he's got a 75 percent chance of keeping it against anyone not named Bob McDonnell, and probably a 55% against the state's current governor. Of course, regardless of whether or not he stays in the senate, Republicans would be barking mad to run anyone for this seat who's name isn't Bob McDonnell. A Warner/McDonnell match-up wouldn't, IMO, be the slam-dunk for Democrats team blue might be assuming. First, McDonnell performed very well in NOVA in 2009, carrying blue-trending Fairfax county (all be it against a fairly lackluster down-state opponent). McDonnell is also seen as a very pragmatic governor who's been effective, while Warner's been a very generic Democrat in the senate. I think a Warner/McDonnell race would be largely determined on the national mood. Unlike George Allen, however, McDonnell is a charismatic and capable candidate.

West Virginia. One political blogger referred to Jay Rockefeller's statement that coal was not going to survive as a "retirement announcement". Tongue in cheek though this observation may have been, it's probably an accurate statement of Democrats' best path to victory here. Bluntly put, I don't see Rockefeller winning reelection here, given how far to the left of the state he's become and how hard WV has turned against national Democrats. Republicans will probably play Charlie Brown with the football to Shelly Moore Capito's Lucy again, but Representative David McKinley is an option if Capito bows out for the umpteenth time. If Rockefeller does hang it up, expect everyone who lost the 2011 Democratic gubernatorial primary to run for this open seat.  

AJNolte :: 2014 very preliminary senate picture.
Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email

On Alaska...
How about the current Republican Mayor of Anchorage (Don't know his Name right now).

Dan Sullivan (n/t)

19, Republican, KS-03
Standing strong with Senator Roberts and Governor Brownback.

[ Parent ]
My gut tells me Parnell will run
He's been in a feud lately with Begich and at only 50, he could have a long senate career if he wants it.  

30/Male/Married/Father of One/Republican/CA-3

Marco Rubio For President!

[ Parent ]
Yeah, very possibly.
His 2008 run indicates he has some national interest. I really like Parnell, and in researching this diary, found Mead Treadwell to be a very interesting guy as well. Parnell probably makes this one tilt R at worst; he's popular and fits the state well.  

male, social, fiscal and foreign policy center-right Republican, in but not of academia, VA-08.

[ Parent ]
Please please let's not run any more Tea Party-types
in Senate and Governor races. We've lost so many seats because of them.  

Missouri 2012
The Tea Party candidate was Sarah Steelman, not Todd Akin. Akin emphasizes social issues, was a big porker, and entrenched in Washington. He's the type the Tea Party was formed to beat. There was only one Tea Party loser in 2012, Richard Mourdock. Perhaps a Tea Party candidate would've fared better than Connie Mack, Tommy Thompson, George Allen, Denny Rehberg, et al. They couldn't have done worse?

R, CA-37; hometown: PA-2

[ Parent ]
yes and no
It's possible to have had margins be worse in that second group.
But only if they had caught the foot-in-mouth disease as well.

43 Male Republican, Maryland Heights, MO Pattonville School District, Maryland Heights Fire District (MO-2). Previously lived in both Memphis and Nashville.

[ Parent ]
I'm not opposed to running Tea Partiers in open seats
Depending on who the candidate is, of course. I was all for Pat Toomey, for instance, but obviously 100 percent against Christine O'Donnell. What I am firmly and always against, however, is mounting primaries from the right against "moderates" like Lugar in this cycle and potentially Graham, Alexander and Cornyn in the next.  

25, MA-07, Rockefeller Republican. Jeb 2016. Visit me at

[ Parent ]
Meh, I don't really care about primaries against Graham or Alexander.
The fact that DeMint can win in SC tells me there's a high tolerance for candidates to the right of Graham. Now, I don't know if likely primary challenger Tom Davis has issues which would prevent him from winning a GE, but I think Republicans could probably win with a good candidate to the right of Graham. The same goes for Tennessee, although I suspect Alexander's in solid enough shape to prevent such a challenge. Tennessee really seems to like moderate Republicans (or, at least, like splitting the conservative vote, and giving the nomination to moderate Republicans).

My rule on Tea Party challenges is pretty simple. If it's a red state in a midterm, go for it. If it's a swing state in a mid-term or a red state in a presidential year, evaluate the quality of your challenger, and the potential Democratic opponent. If it's a swing state in a presidential year or a blue state ever, forget about it.  

male, social, fiscal and foreign policy center-right Republican, in but not of academia, VA-08.

[ Parent ]
Mourdock didn't lose because of ideology
He lost because he was a bad candidate. Mike Pence is a staunch conservative and got elected statewide. When you're running for senate you need to run a good campaign and sometimes, like with Brown and McMahon, that's not enough.

R, CA-37; hometown: PA-2

[ Parent ]
When does Pence
start his 2016 presidential campaign?

[ Parent ]
Too simplistic
I have no problem with GOOD tea party candidates, or GOOD establishment candidates.

Pat Toomey and Rand Paul were winners.

Mourdock, O'Donnell, and Angle were losers.

On the same note.

Akin, Hoekstra, and Thompson lost. They wern't tea party.

Good candidates are good candidates and bad candidates are bad candidates.  

MI-08 - Chairman - Livingston County Republican Party Since 2013 - Opinions are my own and not that of LCRP.  

[ Parent ]
Colorado 2014/2016
To me it is like Minnesota 2012/2014: Why not wait and run against Bennet in 2016, just as serious GOP candidates in Minnesota gave Klobuchar a pass in order to run against Franken (or Dayton for Governor) in 2014.

Jane Norton will likely run in 2014
Because she won't get a free pass through the primary in 2016.

30/Male/Married/Father of One/Republican/CA-3

Marco Rubio For President!

[ Parent ]
Udall is a basically undistinguished liberal, whereas Bennett won in the 2010 wave.
Add to that the fact that Udall is up in a mid-term while Bennett is up in a presidential cycle, and I might challenge Udall over Bennett if I were an ambitious Colorado Republican.  

male, social, fiscal and foreign policy center-right Republican, in but not of academia, VA-08.

[ Parent ]
2014 should be great
The non-Presidential years seem to over-index with older voters, I believe history also shows it generally works against the President.

We should be good, the only worry is how portable the Obama GOTV infrastructure is.

An anti-public union, market-loving moderate.

6 year itch.
I'm hoping that 2014 and 2016 go like 2006 and 2008 in reverse.  

Member, Small Government Caucus

21, Pro-life Libertarian-leaning R, NC-1

[ Parent ]
its looking like
"6 year itch in House" : Unlikely as Obama already had it early. I think we might net ten to fifteen seats from where we are now.

"6 year itch in Senate" : That is much easier. But we need candidates that don't shoot themselves in the foot.

43 Male Republican, Maryland Heights, MO Pattonville School District, Maryland Heights Fire District (MO-2). Previously lived in both Memphis and Nashville.

[ Parent ]
We could have our own Problems with Retirements...
not just the Democrats.

I doubt Senators Cochran, Enzi and Inhofe will run again.

But are those seats vulnerable?
I can't see Democrats being competitive in Wyoming or Oklahoma at all, and Mississippi in a mid-term election.

24, Conservatarian Republican CA-12
Liberals dream things that never were and ask why not.  Conservatives shout back "Because it won't work"

[ Parent ]
Henry & Freudenthal
Just for the record, Brad Henry will be 50 years old during recruitment season. Dave Freudenthal will be 63.

Democrat, NC-11

[ Parent ]
The GOP bench in WY and OK is fine
Lummis would destroy Freudenthal. And my gut tells me that Fallin will run for senate if Inhofe retires. Even if she didn't, given the recent political activity of JC Watts, I think he may give it a go as well.  

30/Male/Married/Father of One/Republican/CA-3

Marco Rubio For President!

[ Parent ]
I see her waiting until 2016 to run. Still, the GOP bench in OK isn't too shabby. I could see Watts, Cole, Lankford, and maybe even Bridenstine running, although he would probably wait until 2016 and hope Fallin doesn't run.  

Male, LA-01
Scott Walker '16

[ Parent ]
Why do you think Fallin would wait until 2016?
Obviously Coburn will retire, but if Inhofe retires, why would she wait to be a junior senator, when she could easily walk into a senate seat in 2014 to become the eventual senior senator?

If such a scenario takes place, I would then doubt she runs for Coburn's seat. But, the really interesting question would be who runs for governor against Todd Lamb if she does run for the senate in 2014.  

30/Male/Married/Father of One/Republican/CA-3

Marco Rubio For President!

[ Parent ]
Good point
On being a Senior Senator. I'm assuming she favors Lamb to succeed her and waiting until 2016 would give him a leg up. But she may not care who succeeds her.  

Male, LA-01
Scott Walker '16

[ Parent ]
No problem
Those are among the easiest states in which to defend an open seat for us.  Getting rid of Cochran would be fantastic, actually.  Huge porker.  

[ Parent ]
From the house: maybe Palazzo or Nunnelee, or Greg Harper could give it a go I guess (I actually had to look Harper up, which is embarrassing). I could also see someone like Tate Reeves running here, and I wouldn't entirely count out national committee man and former first nephew Henry Barbour either. Might businessman Dave Dennis or TV personality Angela McGlowan run as tea party candidates here? Possible, but my sense is, given his former position in the MS state senate, Nunnelee would be a likely candidate in an open seat.

Democrats' only viable candidate would be AG Jim Hood, but given his utter lack of interest in running for governor in 2011, how likely is he to run for an office in DC where he'd be tied to President Obama?

OK: Democrats bench would basically be either Henry or Boren, and I think the issues I mentioned above apply to both of them here as well. I don't think Henry wants to be the Democratic Linda Lingle. The Republican primary would have major clown car potential, absent an entry by Governor Fallin.

WY: Freudenthal = Henry = Hood. The real question is whether Cynthia Lumis gets this primary to herself. I have to think some other WY officials might be interested in moving up to the senate as well. I think I remember reading Enzy was in fact planning to run for reelection, but could be wrong.  

male, social, fiscal and foreign policy center-right Republican, in but not of academia, VA-08.

[ Parent ]
The first comment refers to MS.

male, social, fiscal and foreign policy center-right Republican, in but not of academia, VA-08.

[ Parent ]
In MS it would be crazy, as no one will clear the field. In OK, it won't be so bad if Fallin passes, as I cannot imagine more than one member of congress giving up their seat, if at all. And in WY, it seems like Enzi will announce late, so that if he does retire, Lummis will get the upper hand over any last minute challenger.

30/Male/Married/Father of One/Republican/CA-3

Marco Rubio For President!

[ Parent ]

Advanced Search

(C) RRH Elections
Powered by: SoapBlox